Solved Exercises on Theoretical vs Experimental Probability in Grade 8

Master theoretical vs experimental probability: coin flips, dice rolls, spinner experiments, and probability comparisons through these 5 detailed exercises.

Solution: Exercises 1 to 3
1 Coin Flip Experiment
Exercise 1
A fair coin was flipped 100 times, resulting in 58 heads and 42 tails.
a) Calculate the theoretical probability of getting heads
b) Calculate the experimental probability of getting heads
c) Compare the two probabilities and explain the difference
Definition:

Theoretical probability: The expected probability based on mathematical reasoning. Formula: P(Theoretical) = Number of favorable outcomes / Total possible outcomes

Experimental probability: The observed probability based on actual trials. Formula: P(Experimental) = Number of successful outcomes / Total number of trials

Method for comparing probabilities:
  1. Calculate theoretical probability using the ideal model
  2. Calculate experimental probability using actual results
  3. Compare the two values
  4. Explain why differences occur
Theoretical
1/2 = 0.5
Experimental
58/100 = 0.58
Difference
0.08
Step 1: Calculate theoretical probability

For a fair coin: P(heads) = 1/2 = 0.5 or 50%

Step 2: Calculate experimental probability

P(heads) = 58/100 = 0.58 or 58%

Step 3: Compare the probabilities

Theoretical: 0.50 vs Experimental: 0.58

Difference: |0.58 - 0.50| = 0.08 or 8%

Step 4: Explain the difference

The experimental probability differs from theoretical due to randomness and limited number of trials.

Theoretical: 0.50, Experimental: 0.58, Difference: 0.08
Final answer:

a) Theoretical probability of heads = 0.50 (50%)
b) Experimental probability of heads = 0.58 (58%)
c) The experimental probability is higher than theoretical due to natural variation in small samples.

Applied rules:

• Theoretical: Based on ideal conditions (fair coin has 50% chance)

• Experimental: Based on actual observations from trials

• Law of Large Numbers: As trials increase, experimental approaches theoretical

2 Dice Roll Experiment
Exercise 2
A standard die was rolled 60 times with the following results:
1 appeared 8 times, 2 appeared 12 times, 3 appeared 10 times,
4 appeared 9 times, 5 appeared 11 times, 6 appeared 10 times.
Calculate the theoretical and experimental probability of rolling a 2.
Definition:

Theoretical probability for dice: Each face has equal chance. For a standard 6-sided die: P(any number) = 1/6

Theoretical
1/6 ≈ 0.167
Experimental
12/60 = 0.20
Difference
0.033
Step 1: Calculate theoretical probability

For a fair die: P(rolling 2) = 1/6 ≈ 0.167 or 16.7%

Step 2: Calculate experimental probability

2 appeared 12 times out of 60 rolls: P(2) = 12/60 = 0.20 or 20%

Step 3: Compare the probabilities

Theoretical: 16.7% vs Experimental: 20%

Difference: |0.20 - 0.167| = 0.033 or 3.3%

Step 4: Analyze the result

The experimental probability is slightly higher than theoretical, which is normal for a small number of trials.

Theoretical: 0.167 (16.7%), Experimental: 0.20 (20%)
Final answer:

Theoretical probability of rolling a 2 = 1/6 ≈ 0.167 (16.7%)
Experimental probability of rolling a 2 = 12/60 = 0.20 (20%)

Applied rules:

• Fair die: Each face has equal probability of 1/6

• Experimental: Based on actual frequency of occurrence

• Randomness: Small variations are expected in experiments

3 Spinner Experiment
Exercise 3
A spinner with 4 equal sections (red, blue, green, yellow) was spun 80 times.
Red appeared 22 times, Blue appeared 18 times, Green appeared 20 times, Yellow appeared 20 times.
Calculate the theoretical and experimental probability of landing on red.
Definition:

Spinner probability: For equally sized sections, each color has equal probability. Formula: P(color) = 1/number of sections

Theoretical
1/4 = 0.25
Experimental
22/80 = 0.275
Difference
0.025
Step 1: Calculate theoretical probability

With 4 equal sections: P(red) = 1/4 = 0.25 or 25%

Step 2: Calculate experimental probability

Red appeared 22 times out of 80 spins: P(red) = 22/80 = 0.275 or 27.5%

Step 3: Compare the probabilities

Theoretical: 25% vs Experimental: 27.5%

Difference: |0.275 - 0.25| = 0.025 or 2.5%

Step 4: Interpret the result

The experimental probability is slightly higher than theoretical, which is within expected variation.

Theoretical: 0.25 (25%), Experimental: 0.275 (27.5%)
Final answer:

Theoretical probability of landing on red = 1/4 = 0.25 (25%)
Experimental probability of landing on red = 22/80 = 0.275 (27.5%)

Applied rules:

• Equal sections: Each section has equal probability

• Experimental accuracy: Improves with more trials

• Variation: Small differences are normal in experiments

Rules and methods, laws,...
P(T) = F/T, P(E) = S/N
Theoretical vs Experimental
Theoretical
Favorable/Total
Based on theory
Experimental
Success/Trials
Based on data
Convergence
E(P) → T(P)
As N increases
Key definitions:

Theoretical probability: Probability calculated mathematically based on possible outcomes

Experimental probability: Probability calculated based on actual experimental results

Sample space: Set of all possible outcomes

Event: Specific outcome or set of outcomes

Complete methodology:
  1. Identify the event: Determine what outcome you're measuring
  2. Calculate theoretical: Use mathematical model
  3. Calculate experimental: Use actual trial data
  4. Compare: Analyze differences and reasons
  5. Interpret: Understand implications
Tip 1: Theoretical probability stays constant, experimental varies with each experiment.
Tip 2: More trials lead to experimental probability approaching theoretical probability.
Tip 3: Theoretical is what "should" happen, experimental is what "actually" happened.
Tip 4: Always express probabilities as fractions, decimals, or percentages.
Common errors: Confusing formulas, miscounting outcomes, forgetting to simplify fractions.
Exam preparation: Practice both calculations, understand law of large numbers, work with various experiments.
Formulas to know by heart:

• Theoretical Probability: P = Favorable Outcomes ÷ Total Possible Outcomes

• Experimental Probability: P = Successes ÷ Total Trials

• Law of Large Numbers: As trials increase, experimental → theoretical

• All probabilities are between 0 and 1 (or 0% and 100%)

Solution: Exercises 4 to 5
4 Probability Comparison
Exercise 4
A bag contains 3 red marbles, 4 blue marbles, and 5 green marbles.
Theoretical probability of drawing a blue marble is calculated.
Then 120 draws were made (with replacement), and 42 blue marbles were drawn.
Calculate both probabilities and determine which is closer to the theoretical value.
Definition:

Marble drawing probability: With replacement, probabilities remain constant for each draw

Theoretical
4/12 = 1/3
Experimental
42/120 = 0.35
Difference
0.017
Step 1: Calculate theoretical probability

Total marbles: 3 + 4 + 5 = 12
Blue marbles: 4
P(blue) = 4/12 = 1/3 ≈ 0.333 or 33.3%

Step 2: Calculate experimental probability

Blue drawn: 42 times out of 120 trials
P(blue) = 42/120 = 0.35 or 35%

Step 3: Compare and analyze

Theoretical: 33.3% vs Experimental: 35%
Difference: |0.35 - 0.333| = 0.017 or 1.7%

Step 4: Conclusion

The experimental probability (35%) is very close to theoretical (33.3%), showing good agreement.

Theoretical: 1/3 ≈ 0.333, Experimental: 0.35, Difference: 0.017
Final answer:

Theoretical probability of drawing blue = 1/3 ≈ 0.333 (33.3%)
Experimental probability of drawing blue = 42/120 = 0.35 (35%)
The experimental result is quite close to theoretical, with only a 1.7% difference.

Applied rules:

• With replacement: Probabilities remain constant for each draw

• Large sample: 120 trials provide good experimental data

• Small difference: Indicates the experiment aligned well with theory

5 Long-term Probability Study
Exercise 5
A student conducts an experiment flipping a coin multiple times:
After 50 flips: 28 heads
After 100 flips: 58 heads
After 200 flips: 101 heads
Calculate the experimental probability after each stage and observe the trend toward theoretical probability.
Definition:

Law of Large Numbers: As the number of trials increases, experimental probability approaches theoretical probability

After 50
28/50 = 0.56
After 100
58/100 = 0.58
After 200
101/200 = 0.505
Step 1: Calculate after 50 flips

P(heads) = 28/50 = 0.56 or 56%

Difference from theoretical (0.50): |0.56 - 0.50| = 0.06

Step 2: Calculate after 100 flips

P(heads) = 58/100 = 0.58 or 58%

Difference from theoretical: |0.58 - 0.50| = 0.08

Step 3: Calculate after 200 flips

P(heads) = 101/200 = 0.505 or 50.5%

Difference from theoretical: |0.505 - 0.50| = 0.005

Step 4: Observe the trend

As trials increase (50→100→200), experimental probability approaches theoretical (0.50)

50 flips: 0.56, 100 flips: 0.58, 200 flips: 0.505
Final answer:

After 50 flips: 0.56 (56%), after 100 flips: 0.58 (58%), after 200 flips: 0.505 (50.5%)
The experimental probability converges toward the theoretical probability of 0.50 as the number of trials increases, demonstrating the Law of Large Numbers.

Applied rules:

• Law of Large Numbers: More trials → better approximation to theoretical

• Convergence: Experimental probability gets closer to theoretical over time

• Stability: Larger sample sizes provide more stable results

Key Concepts: Definitions, Formulas, Methods, Tips
P(T) = F/T, P(E) = S/N
Probability Concepts
Key definitions:

Theoretical probability: Probability calculated mathematically based on all possible outcomes assuming ideal conditions

Experimental probability: Probability calculated based on actual experimental results from repeated trials

Sample space: The set of all possible outcomes of an experiment

Event: A specific outcome or set of outcomes in the sample space

Law of Large Numbers: As the number of trials increases, experimental probability approaches theoretical probability

Complete methodology:
  1. Define the event: Identify the specific outcome you're interested in
  2. Calculate theoretical: Use mathematical model to determine expected probability
  3. Conduct experiment: Perform trials and record actual results
  4. Calculate experimental: Use actual results to determine observed probability
  5. Analyze differences: Compare and explain any discrepancies
Tip 1: Theoretical probability remains constant, experimental probability varies with each experiment.
Tip 2: The larger the number of trials, the closer experimental probability gets to theoretical probability.
Tip 3: Always express probabilities as fractions, decimals, or percentages for clarity.
Tip 4: Differences between theoretical and experimental are normal, especially with small sample sizes.
Common errors: Miscounting outcomes, confusing formulas, expecting exact matches, ignoring sample size effects.
Exam preparation: Practice both calculations, understand the law of large numbers, work with various probability experiments.
Formulas to know by heart:

• Theoretical Probability: P = (Number of favorable outcomes) ÷ (Total number of possible outcomes)

• Experimental Probability: P = (Number of successful outcomes) ÷ (Total number of trials)

• Law of Large Numbers: As N → ∞, Experimental P → Theoretical P

• All probabilities satisfy: 0 ≤ P ≤ 1 (or 0% ≤ P ≤ 100%)

Detailed Summary: Theoretical vs Experimental Probability
Core Definitions

Theoretical Probability: The expected probability of an event based on mathematical reasoning and the assumption of ideal conditions. It's calculated using the formula: P(theoretical) = (favorable outcomes) ÷ (total possible outcomes).

Experimental Probability: The observed probability of an event based on actual experiments and recorded data. It's calculated using the formula: P(experimental) = (successful outcomes) ÷ (total trials).

Core Rules and Laws

Basic Probability Rule: All probabilities range from 0 to 1 (or 0% to 100%), where 0 means impossible and 1 means certain.

Law of Large Numbers: As the number of trials increases, the experimental probability will approach the theoretical probability.

Equally Likely Outcomes: When all outcomes have the same chance of occurring, theoretical probability is straightforward to calculate.

Step-by-Step Methods

Calculating Theoretical Probability:

  1. Identify the sample space (all possible outcomes)
  2. Count the favorable outcomes
  3. Apply the formula: P = favorable ÷ total
  4. Simplify the fraction or convert to decimal/percentage

Calculating Experimental Probability:

  1. Perform the experiment and record results
  2. Count the number of successful outcomes
  3. Count the total number of trials
  4. Apply the formula: P = successes ÷ trials
Examples and Applications

Simple Example: Flipping a fair coin

Theoretical: P(heads) = 1/2 = 0.5 (50%)

Experimental: After 100 flips with 48 heads: P(heads) = 48/100 = 0.48 (48%)

Advanced Example: Rolling two dice and getting a sum of 7

Theoretical: There are 6 ways to get a sum of 7 out of 36 possible outcomes: P(sum=7) = 6/36 = 1/6 ≈ 0.167

Tips and Common Pitfalls

Tips:

  • Always clearly define what constitutes a "success" in your experiment
  • More trials generally yield more accurate experimental probabilities
  • Express probabilities consistently (all fractions, decimals, or percentages)
  • Understand that small differences between theoretical and experimental are normal

Common Mistakes:

  • Confusing the formulas for theoretical and experimental probability
  • Expecting exact matches between theoretical and experimental values
  • Not considering whether outcomes are truly equally likely
  • Forgetting to account for sample size in experimental results
Key Notes for Memorization

Theoretical = What Should Happen (based on math)

Experimental = What Actually Happened (based on data)

More Trials = Better Approximation (law of large numbers)

Both Must Be Between 0 and 1 (inclusive)

Differences Are Normal (especially with few trials)

Questions & Answers

Question: Why do theoretical and experimental probabilities sometimes differ? Shouldn't they be the same?

Answer: Great question! Theoretical and experimental probabilities often differ because:

  • Theoretical probability assumes ideal conditions and infinite trials
  • Experimental probability reflects real-world randomness and finite trials
  • Natural variation occurs in any random process
  • Sample size affects how closely experimental matches theoretical

For example, when flipping a coin 10 times, you might get 7 heads (70%), but theoretically it should be 50%. However, after 1000 flips, you'd expect to be much closer to 50%.

The Law of Large Numbers states that as the number of trials increases, experimental probability will approach theoretical probability.

Question: How many trials do I need for experimental probability to match theoretical probability?

Answer: There's no exact number where experimental probability will perfectly match theoretical, but here are guidelines:

  • Small trials (10-50): Significant variation is expected
  • Moderate trials (100-500): Closer to theoretical, but some variation
  • Large trials (1000+): Very close to theoretical probability

The key concept is that experimental probability approaches theoretical probability as trials increase, but may never be exactly equal. The larger your sample size, the more confident you can be that your experimental probability is a good estimate of the theoretical probability.

In practice, even with 1000 trials, there might still be a small difference due to natural randomness.

Question: Can experimental probability ever be more accurate than theoretical probability?

Answer: Yes, in certain situations! This happens when:

  • The theoretical model is incorrect - For example, if a coin isn't truly fair but we assume it is
  • Real-world factors affect outcomes - Environmental conditions, wear and tear, bias in equipment
  • We have a large sample size - Experimental data can reveal actual probabilities

For instance, if a die appears fair but is actually weighted, the theoretical probability assumes each face has 1/6 chance, but experimental probability after thousands of rolls might reveal different true probabilities.

However, theoretical probability remains valuable as it provides a baseline expectation and helps us understand the underlying system.

The relationship is complementary: theoretical gives us expectations, experimental reveals reality.