Solved Exercises on Tessellations and Symmetry in Geometry

Master tessellations and symmetry: regular tessellations, semi-regular tessellations, symmetry groups, and pattern identification through these 5 detailed exercises.

Solution: Exercises 1 to 3
1 Regular tessellation
Exercise 1
Determine which regular polygons can form regular tessellations and explain why.
Definition:

Regular Tessellation: A tessellation formed by congruent regular polygons meeting edge-to-edge.

Regular Polygon: A polygon with all sides and all angles equal.

Tessellation Analysis Method:
  1. Calculate the interior angle of the regular polygon
  2. Determine if the interior angle divides evenly into 360°
  3. Check if the quotient is a whole number (number of polygons meeting at each vertex)
Formula
Interior angle = (n-2)×180°/n
Method
Angle Analysis
Step 1: Calculate interior angles

Triangle (n=3): (3-2)×180°/3 = 60°
Square (n=4): (4-2)×180°/4 = 90°
Pentagon (n=5): (5-2)×180°/5 = 108°
Hexagon (n=6): (6-2)×180°/6 = 120°

Step 2: Check divisibility into 360°

360° ÷ 60° = 6 ✓
360° ÷ 90° = 4 ✓
360° ÷ 108° = 3.33... ✗
360° ÷ 120° = 3 ✓

Step 3: Verify for higher polygons

For n ≥ 7: Interior angle > 128.57°, so 360° ÷ angle < 2.8, not an integer

Step 4: Conclusion

Only equilateral triangles, squares, and regular hexagons can form regular tessellations

Only 3 regular tessellations exist
Final answer:

Only three regular tessellations are possible: using equilateral triangles (6 at each vertex), squares (4 at each vertex), and regular hexagons (3 at each vertex).

Applied rules:

• Interior Angle Formula: (n-2)×180°/n

• Tessellation Condition: 360° must be divisible by interior angle

• Integer Requirement: Number of polygons at vertex must be whole number

2 Semi-regular tessellation
Exercise 2
Identify the vertex configuration of a semi-regular tessellation that uses squares and octagons. Show that this configuration satisfies the tessellation requirements.
Definition:

Semi-Regular Tessellation: A tessellation using two or more types of regular polygons with the same arrangement at each vertex.

Vertex Configuration: The sequence of polygon types meeting at each vertex.

Formula
Sum of angles = 360°
Method
Angle Sum
Result
(4,8,8)
Step 1: Calculate interior angles

Square: 90°
Octagon: (8-2)×180°/8 = 135°

Step 2: Find possible combinations

We need: 90° + 135° + 135° = 360°

Step 3: Verify the combination

One square and two octagons: 90° + 135° + 135° = 360° ✓

Step 4: Write vertex configuration

Configuration is (4,8,8) - one square and two octagons meeting at each vertex

Vertex configuration: (4,8,8)
Final answer:

The semi-regular tessellation using squares and octagons has vertex configuration (4,8,8), meaning one square and two octagons meet at each vertex. This satisfies the requirement since 90° + 135° + 135° = 360°.

Applied rules:

• Angle Sum Condition: Angles at each vertex must sum to 360°

• Vertex Uniformity: Same configuration at every vertex

• Regular Polygon Angles: (n-2)×180°/n

3 Symmetry group analysis
Exercise 3
Analyze the symmetry group of a regular hexagonal tessellation. Identify all types of symmetry present.
Definition:

Symmetry Group: The set of all transformations that map a pattern onto itself.

Types of Symmetry: Translation, rotation, reflection, and glide reflection.

Symmetry Types
6 types
Method
Group Analysis
Result
p6m
Step 1: Identify rotational symmetry

Hexagons have 6-fold rotational symmetry: rotations by 60°, 120°, 180°, 240°, 300°

Step 2: Identify reflection symmetry

Multiple reflection axes: through vertices and through midpoints of opposite sides

Step 3: Identify translational symmetry

Pattern repeats in multiple directions (hexagonal lattice)

Step 4: Identify glide reflection

Combination of translation and reflection symmetry

Step 5: Determine symmetry group

This is the p6m group (hexagonal/triangular symmetry group)

Symmetry group: p6m
Final answer:

The regular hexagonal tessellation has the p6m symmetry group, featuring 6-fold rotational symmetry, multiple reflection axes, translational symmetry, and glide reflection symmetries.

Applied rules:

• Rotational Symmetry: n-fold for regular n-gon tessellations

• Reflection Symmetry: Axes through vertices and edge midpoints

• Translation Symmetry: Pattern repeats in fundamental directions

Tessellations and Symmetry Principles
(n-2) \times 180°/n
Interior Angle Formula
Regular Tessellations
3 possible types
Triangles, squares, hexagons
Semi-Regular Tessellations
8 possible types
Multiple polygon combinations
Wallpaper Groups
17 symmetry types
Complete classification
Key Definitions:

Tessellation: A pattern of shapes that covers a plane with no gaps or overlaps.

Regular Tessellation: Uses only one type of regular polygon.

Semi-Regular Tessellation: Uses two or more regular polygons with the same vertex configuration.

Symmetry Group: The collection of all symmetries of a pattern.

Analysis Methods:
  1. Angle Sum Method: Check if interior angles sum to 360° at vertices
  2. Vertex Configuration: Determine polygon arrangements
  3. Group Classification: Identify symmetry types
  4. Pattern Recognition: Match with known tessellations
Regular Tessellation Limitation: Only 3 regular tessellations exist due to angle constraints.
Symmetry Types: Translation, rotation, reflection, and glide reflection.
Wallpaper Groups: There are exactly 17 distinct symmetry groups for periodic patterns.
Tip 1: Remember that the interior angle of a regular n-gon is (n-2)×180°/n.
Tip 2: For tessellations, the angles at each vertex must sum to exactly 360°.
Tip 3: Look for the fundamental region when analyzing symmetry groups.
Solution: Exercises 4 to 5
4 Escher-style tessellation
Exercise 4
Create a tessellation using a modified square that incorporates both rotational and reflection symmetry. Explain the transformation process.
Definition:

Modified Tessellation: A pattern created by altering basic shapes while maintaining tessellation properties.

Escher Tessellation: Artistic tessellations with recognizable motifs.

Method
Shape Modification
Process
Transformation
Result
New Motif
Step 1: Start with a basic square

Begin with a square that tessellates regularly

Step 2: Modify one side

Add a shape to one side of the square and subtract the same shape from the opposite side

Step 3: Apply to adjacent sides

Add a shape to the top and subtract the same shape from the bottom

Step 4: Verify tessellation property

Check that the modified shape still fits together without gaps

Step 5: Analyze resulting symmetries

The modified shape preserves the underlying square lattice symmetries

Modified tessellation created
Final answer:

The modified square tessellation maintains the original symmetries while creating a new visual motif. The transformation preserves the fundamental properties of the tessellation while allowing for artistic creativity.

Applied rules:

• Area Conservation: Added and subtracted shapes must balance

• Edge Matching: Adjacent tiles must fit perfectly

• Symmetry Preservation: Underlying lattice symmetries maintained

5 Penrose tiling analysis
Exercise 5
Explain the properties of a Penrose tiling using rhombuses and compare its symmetry to periodic tessellations.
Definition:

Penrose Tiling: A non-periodic tiling using two types of rhombuses.

Non-Periodic: Lacks translational symmetry in any direction.

Type
Non-periodic
Shapes
2 rhombuses
Symmetry
5-fold
Step 1: Identify the two rhombus types

Thin rhombus (36°, 144°) and thick rhombus (72°, 108°)

Step 2: Explain aperiodicity

Pattern never repeats exactly, unlike periodic tessellations

Step 3: Describe 5-fold symmetry

Local 5-fold rotational symmetry but no global periodicity

Step 4: Compare with periodic tilings

Periodic tilings have translational symmetry; Penrose tilings do not

Step 5: Note quasicrystal connection

Related to quasicrystals found in nature

Non-periodic with local 5-fold symmetry
Final answer:

Penrose tiling uses two rhombus shapes to create a non-periodic pattern with local 5-fold symmetry. Unlike periodic tessellations, it lacks translational symmetry but exhibits intricate local symmetries and self-similarity.

Applied rules:

• Aperiodicity: No translational symmetry

• Local vs Global Symmetry: Local symmetries differ from global

• Self-Similarity: Pattern appears similar at different scales

Complete Guide: Tessellations and Symmetry
\text{Tessellation condition: } \sum_{i} \theta_i = 360°
Tessellation Angle Condition
Key definitions:

Tessellation: A covering of a plane with shapes that fit together without gaps or overlaps.

Regular Tessellation: Using only one type of regular polygon with identical vertex configurations.

Semi-Regular Tessellation: Using two or more regular polygons with the same vertex configuration at each vertex.

Symmetry Group: The set of all isometries that preserve the pattern.

Complete methodology:
  1. Identify the shapes: Determine which polygons are used
  2. Calculate angles: Use interior angle formula for regular polygons
  3. Check vertex condition: Verify that angles sum to 360°
  4. Verify tessellation: Ensure shapes fit together without gaps
  5. Analyze symmetries: Identify all transformation types
Tip 1: For regular tessellations, only 3 types are possible: triangles, squares, and hexagons.
Tip 2: In semi-regular tessellations, the vertex configuration must be consistent everywhere.
Tip 3: Remember that the sum of angles at each vertex must equal 360°.
Tip 4: Look for the fundamental region when analyzing complex patterns.
Common errors: Forgetting to check that angles sum to 360°, misidentifying vertex configurations.
Exam preparation: Know the 3 regular tessellations and several semi-regular ones.
Formulas to know by heart:

• Interior Angle: (n-2)×180°/n for regular n-gon

• Tessellation Condition: Sum of angles at vertex = 360°

• Vertex Configuration: List polygon types in order around vertex

• Rotation Symmetry: n-fold if rotates by 360°/n

Tessellation Types and Properties
Exercise 6: Symmetry Analysis
Compare symmetry properties of different tessellations:
• Regular
• Semi-regular
• Demi-regular
• Non-periodic

Analysis: Different tessellation types exhibit varying levels of symmetry and complexity.

  • Regular: Highest symmetry, simplest patterns
  • Semi-regular: Moderate symmetry, more complex
  • Demi-regular: Lower symmetry, complex patterns
  • Non-periodic: Unique local symmetries

Questions & Answers

Question: Why can't regular pentagons form a regular tessellation? They seem like they should fit together.

Answer: This is a common misconception! Let's look at the math:

  • Interior angle of regular pentagon: (5-2)×180°/5 = 540°/5 = 108°
  • To tessellate: We need 360° ÷ 108° = 3.33... polygons at each vertex
  • Problem: We can't have 3.33 polygons meeting at a point!

If you try to place three pentagons together, you get 3 × 108° = 324°, leaving a 36° gap. If you try four, you get 4 × 108° = 432°, which is 72° too much.

This is why only triangles (60°), squares (90°), and hexagons (120°) can form regular tessellations, as 360° divides evenly by these angles.

There are irregular pentagons that can tessellate, but not regular ones.

Question: What's the difference between semi-regular and demi-regular tessellations? I've seen both terms.

Answer: The terminology can be confusing, but here's the distinction:

  • Semi-Regular Tessellations: Use two or more regular polygons with the same vertex configuration at every vertex. There are exactly 8 such tessellations.
  • Demi-Regular Tessellations: Also called "uniform tilings," this category includes both regular and semi-regular tessellations. However, sometimes it refers to tessellations with more complex vertex arrangements.

More specifically, the 8 semi-regular tessellations have vertex configurations like: - (3,6,3,6) - triangles and hexagons alternating - (4,8,8) - squares and octagons - (3,4,6,4) - triangles, squares, and hexagons

For your studies, focus on the 8 semi-regular tessellations and their vertex configurations. These are standardized and well-defined.

Question: What are the 17 wallpaper groups? Do I need to know all of them?

Answer: The 17 wallpaper groups classify all possible symmetry patterns in the plane. They represent every possible combination of translations, rotations, reflections, and glide reflections:

  • Names: Each has a symbol like p1, p2, pm, pg, cm, pmm, pmg, pgg, cmm, p4, p4m, p4g, p3, p3m1, p31m, p6, p6m
  • p6m: The most symmetric, includes regular hexagonal tessellations
  • p1: The least symmetric, only translations

For high school geometry, you don't need to memorize all 17. Focus on recognizing the main types: - p1 (translations only) - p2 (translations and 2-fold rotations) - p4m (includes square grids) - p6m (includes hexagonal tessellations)

Understanding that there are exactly 17 distinct types is more important than knowing all their names and symbols.