Solved Exercises on Probability Distributions Applications (Games, Decisions)

Master probability distributions applications in games and decision-making: calculating expected values, analyzing risks, and making informed choices through these 5 detailed exercises.

Solution: Exercises 1 to 3
1 Casino Game Analysis
Exercise 1
A casino game costs $5 to play. You roll a fair die. If you roll a 6, you win $20. If you roll a 4 or 5, you win $10. Otherwise, you win nothing. Calculate the expected value of playing this game and decide if it's worth playing from a player's perspective.
Definition:

Expected Value: The long-run average outcome of a random variable.

Net Winnings: Gross winnings minus cost to play.

Worth Playing: If E[Net Winnings] > 0, it's favorable to player; if < 0, it's unfavorable.

Method for game analysis:
  1. Identify all possible outcomes and their probabilities
  2. Calculate net winnings for each outcome (gross - cost)
  3. Calculate expected value: E[Net Winnings] = Σ [net_winnings × P(outcome)]
  4. Make decision based on sign of expected value
Die Roll Gross Winnings Net Winnings Probability Net × Prob 6 $20 $15 1/6 15 × 1/6 = $2.50 4, 5 $10 $5 2/6 = 1/3 5 × 1/3 = $1.67 1, 2, 3 $0 -$5 3/6 = 1/2 -5 × 1/2 = -$2.50
Step 1: Identify outcomes and probabilities

Roll 6: P = 1/6, Net = $20 - $5 = $15

Roll 4 or 5: P = 2/6 = 1/3, Net = $10 - $5 = $5

Roll 1, 2, or 3: P = 3/6 = 1/2, Net = $0 - $5 = -$5

Step 2: Calculate expected value

E[Net Winnings] = $15 × 1/6 + $5 × 1/3 + (-$5) × 1/2

= $2.50 + $1.67 - $2.50 = $1.67

Step 3: Make decision

Since E[Net Winnings] = $1.67 > 0, the game is favorable to the player.

On average, a player gains $1.67 per game played.

Step 4: Verify probabilities sum to 1

1/6 + 1/3 + 1/2 = 1/6 + 2/6 + 3/6 = 6/6 = 1 ✓

E[Net]
+$1.67
Decision
Play
House Edge
-$1.67
E[Net Winnings] = $1.67 (worth playing)
Final answer:

The expected net winnings are $1.67 per game.

This game is favorable to the player and worth playing.

Applied rules:

• Expected Value Formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Net Winnings: Gross winnings minus cost

• Game Evaluation: Positive EV favors player, negative favors house

2 Investment Decision
Exercise 2
You are considering two investment options. Investment A has a 70% chance of returning $10,000 and a 30% chance of losing $5,000. Investment B has a 50% chance of returning $15,000 and a 50% chance of losing $3,000. Which investment has the higher expected return?
Definition:

Expected Return: The weighted average of all possible returns, weighted by their probabilities.

Investment Decision: Choose option with higher expected return (assuming risk neutrality).

Investment A Outcome Return Probability Product Success $10,000 0.7 $7,000 Loss -$5,000 0.3 -$1,500 Total 1.0 E[A] = $5,500
Investment B Outcome Return Probability Product Success $15,000 0.5 $7,500 Loss -$3,000 0.5 -$1,500 Total 1.0 E[B] = $6,000
Step 1: Calculate expected return for Investment A

E[A] = $10,000 × 0.7 + (-$5,000) × 0.3

= $7,000 - $1,500 = $5,500

Step 2: Calculate expected return for Investment B

E[B] = $15,000 × 0.5 + (-$3,000) × 0.5

= $7,500 - $1,500 = $6,000

Step 3: Compare expected returns

E[A] = $5,500, E[B] = $6,000

Since $6,000 > $5,500, Investment B has the higher expected return

Step 4: Consider risk factors

Investment B: Higher potential gain but also higher potential loss

Investment A: More conservative with lower variance

E[A]
$5,500
E[B]
$6,000
Choice
B
Investment B: E[B] = $6,000 > E[A] = $5,500
Final answer:

Investment B has the higher expected return of $6,000 compared to Investment A's $5,500.

Based on expected value alone, Investment B is the better choice.

Applied rules:

• Expected Value Formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Investment Comparison: Choose option with higher expected value

• Expected Value Dominance: Higher EV indicates better long-term outcome

3 Video Game Achievement Probability
Exercise 3
In a video game, you have a 20% chance of completing a difficult challenge each attempt. The challenge rewards 500 points. It costs 100 points to attempt. What is the expected value of attempting the challenge once? What is the expected value if you keep trying until you succeed?
Definition:

Single Attempt: Binomial-like scenario with two outcomes.

Keep Trying Until Success: Geometric distribution scenario.

Net Reward: Points gained minus points spent.

Outcome Points Gained Cost Net Points Probability Net × Prob Success 500 100 400 0.2 400 × 0.2 = 80 Failure 0 100 -100 0.8 -100 × 0.8 = -80 Total 1.0 E[Single] = 0
Step 1: Calculate expected value for single attempt

E[Single] = 400 × 0.2 + (-100) × 0.8 = 80 - 80 = 0

Step 2: Analyze "keep trying" scenario

This follows geometric distribution. Expected number of attempts until first success = 1/p = 1/0.2 = 5

Expected total cost = 5 × 100 = 500 points

Expected total reward = 500 points (received once)

Expected net = 500 - 500 = 0

Step 3: Calculate expected value for "keep trying" strategy

E[Keep Trying] = Reward - (Expected Attempts × Cost per Attempt)

= 500 - (5 × 100) = 0

Step 4: Interpret results

Both strategies have expected value of 0 points

The game is fair - neither advantageous nor disadvantageous

E[Single]
0
E[Keep]
0
Fair Game
Yes
E[Single] = 0, E[Keep Trying] = 0
Final answer:

The expected value of a single attempt is 0 points.

The expected value of keeping trying until success is also 0 points.

This is a fair game with no advantage to either strategy.

Applied rules:

• Expected Value Formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Geometric Distribution: Expected attempts until success = 1/p

• Fair Game: Expected value of 0 indicates no advantage

Probability Distributions: Games and Decisions
E[X] = \sum_{i} x_i \cdot P(X = x_i)
Expected Value Formula
Decision Rule
E[X] > 0
Worth pursuing
Risk Measure
Var(X)
Uncertainty level
Key definitions:

Expected Value: The long-run average outcome of a random variable, representing the center of the probability distribution.

Net Winnings: Total earnings minus total costs in a game or investment.

Fair Game: A game where expected net winnings equal zero.

Risk-Neutral: Decision maker who focuses only on expected value, ignoring variance.

Decision Criteria: Choose option with highest expected value (for risk-neutral decision makers).
Game Classification: E[Net] > 0 (favorable), E[Net] = 0 (fair), E[Net] < 0 (unfavorable).
Tip 1: Always calculate net outcomes (earnings - costs) when analyzing games/investments.
Tip 2: For "until success" scenarios, use geometric distribution properties.
Tip 3: Consider both expected value AND risk (variance) for comprehensive analysis.
Essential formulas:

• Expected Value: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Net Winnings: Gross - Costs

• Geometric Mean Trials: E[T] = 1/p

• Linear Transformation: E[aX + b] = aE[X] + b

Solution: Exercises 4 to 5
4 Insurance Decision
Exercise 4
You own a $10,000 piece of equipment. There's a 3% chance it will be damaged in an accident, resulting in a $10,000 loss. An insurance policy costs $400 and covers full damage. Should you buy the insurance based on expected value? What if the probability of damage is 8%?
Definition:

Insurance Decision: Compare expected cost of risk vs. cost of insurance.

Expected Loss: Probability of event × Potential loss.

Step 1: Calculate expected loss without insurance (3% probability)

E[Loss without insurance] = $10,000 × 0.03 + $0 × 0.97 = $300

Step 2: Calculate expected cost with insurance (3% probability)

E[Cost with insurance] = $400 (insurance premium)

Insurance covers all damage, so expected out-of-pocket = $400

Step 3: Make decision for 3% probability

Without insurance: Expected cost = $300

With insurance: Expected cost = $400

Since $300 < $400, insurance is not recommended at 3% probability

Step 4: Recalculate for 8% probability

E[Loss without insurance] = $10,000 × 0.08 + $0 × 0.92 = $800

E[Cost with insurance] = $400 (same premium)

Since $800 > $400, insurance is recommended at 8% probability

Step 5: Find break-even probability

Break-even when: Probability × $10,000 = $400

Probability = $400/$10,000 = 0.04 = 4%

3% Prob
No Ins
8% Prob
Buy Ins
Break-even
4%
3%: No insurance, 8%: Buy insurance, Break-even: 4%
Final answer:

At 3% probability, don't buy insurance (expected cost $300 vs $400).

At 8% probability, buy insurance (expected cost $800 vs $400).

Break-even occurs at 4% probability.

Applied rules:

• Expected Value Formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Insurance Decision: Buy if E[Loss] > Premium

• Break-even Analysis: Set E[Cost without] = E[Cost with]

5 Technology Purchase Decision
Exercise 5
You're deciding between two smartphones. Phone A costs $800 and has a 10% chance of needing a $200 repair in the next year. Phone B costs $1000 and has a 5% chance of needing a $150 repair. Which phone has the lower expected total cost over the next year?
Definition:

Total Expected Cost: Purchase price + Expected repair cost.

Repair Probability: Likelihood of requiring repairs within specified time frame.

Step 1: Calculate expected repair cost for Phone A

E[Repair Cost A] = $200 × 0.10 + $0 × 0.90 = $20

Step 2: Calculate total expected cost for Phone A

Total Cost A = Purchase Price + E[Repair Cost]

= $800 + $20 = $820

Step 3: Calculate expected repair cost for Phone B

E[Repair Cost B] = $150 × 0.05 + $0 × 0.95 = $7.50

Step 4: Calculate total expected cost for Phone B

Total Cost B = Purchase Price + E[Repair Cost]

= $1000 + $7.50 = $1007.50

Step 5: Make decision

Total Cost A = $820, Total Cost B = $1007.50

Since $820 < $1007.50, Phone A has the lower expected total cost

Step 6: Consider risk profile

Phone A: Lower upfront cost but higher repair probability

Phone B: Higher upfront cost but lower repair probability

Phone A
$820
Phone B
$1007.50
Choice
A
Phone A: $820 < Phone B: $1007.50
Final answer:

Phone A has the lower expected total cost of $820 compared to Phone B's $1007.50.

Based on expected value, Phone A is the better financial choice.

Applied rules:

• Expected Value Formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Total Expected Cost: Purchase Price + E[Future Costs]

• Decision Rule: Choose option with lowest expected total cost

Probability Distributions Applications: Comprehensive Summary

Complete Summary: Probability Distributions Applications in Games and Decisions

Core Concepts

Expected Value: The weighted average of all possible outcomes, weighted by their probabilities.

Net Value: Gross outcomes minus associated costs.

Decision Rule: Choose option with highest expected value (for risk-neutral decision makers).

Game Fairness: E[Net] = 0 (fair), E[Net] > 0 (favorable), E[Net] < 0 (unfavorable).

Key Properties

Linearity: E[aX + b] = aE[X] + b for constants a, b.

Additivity: E[X + Y] = E[X] + E[Y] for any two random variables.

Probability Weighting: More likely outcomes contribute more to expected value.

Long-run Average: The theoretical average over infinite repetitions.

Decision-Making Process

Step 1: Identify all possible outcomes and their probabilities.

Step 2: Calculate net value for each outcome.

Step 3: Apply expected value formula: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)].

Step 4: Compare options and make decision based on expected values.

Problem-Solving Tips

Always Calculate Net: Subtract costs from gross amounts to get net outcomes.

Verify Probabilities: Ensure all probabilities sum to 1.

Consider Context: Expected value is optimal for risk-neutral decision makers.

Look for Break-even Points: Find thresholds where decisions change.

Detailed Definitions:

Expected Value: The theoretical average value of a random variable over many repetitions of an experiment. It represents the center of the probability distribution.

Risk-Neutral Decision Maker: Someone who makes decisions based solely on expected value, ignoring the variance or risk involved.

Utility Theory: A framework that accounts for risk preferences beyond just expected value, recognizing that people may value certainty differently.

Opportunity Cost: The value of the next best alternative foregone when making a decision.

Present Value: The current value of a future payment or stream of payments, discounted at an appropriate rate.

Systematic Decision-Making Method:
  1. Define the Problem: What decision needs to be made?
  2. Identify Alternatives: List all possible choices.
  3. Determine Outcomes: For each alternative, identify all possible outcomes.
  4. Assign Probabilities: Estimate probability of each outcome.
  5. Calculate Values: Determine monetary or utility value of each outcome.
  6. Compute Expected Values: Apply E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)] for each alternative.
  7. Make Decision: Choose alternative with highest expected value.
Memory Tip: "Expected value = average outcome weighted by probability of occurrence."
Common Mistake: Forgetting to account for all costs when calculating net outcomes.
Efficiency Tip: Create a table to organize outcomes, probabilities, and values systematically.
Application Tip: Expected value helps in comparing options with uncertain outcomes.
Key Applications: Gambling, investing, insurance, purchasing decisions, business strategy, game theory.
Limitations: Expected value ignores risk tolerance, variance, and psychological factors.
Critical Formulas to Remember:

• Expected Value: E[X] = Σ [x × P(X = x)]

• Linear Transformation: E[aX + b] = aE[X] + b

• Additivity: E[X + Y] = E[X] + E[Y]

• Net Calculation: Net = Gross - Costs

Questions & Answers

Question: In Exercise 1, the expected value was positive, meaning the game is favorable to the player. But shouldn't casinos always have the edge? How is this possible?

Answer: You're correct that real casinos always have a positive edge! This is just a hypothetical example to demonstrate the concept.

Real Casino Games:

  • Blackjack house edge: 0.5-2% (with basic strategy)
  • Roulette house edge: 2.7% (European) or 5.26% (American)
  • Slot machines: 2-15% house edge

Why Casinos Must Have Edge:

  • They need to cover operational costs (staff, rent, maintenance)
  • They need to make a profit to stay in business
  • They must pay taxes and dividends

In our example, a real casino would adjust the payouts to ensure a positive house edge, making E[Net] negative for the player.

Question: In Exercise 4, you said not to buy insurance at 3% probability. But wouldn't someone want insurance anyway to protect against the catastrophic loss of $10,000?

Answer: Excellent observation! You've identified a key limitation of pure expected value analysis.

Expected Value vs. Risk Management:

  • Expected value is optimal for risk-neutral individuals
  • Most people are risk-averse and willing to pay extra to avoid large losses
  • Insurance provides peace of mind and protection against catastrophic losses

Utility Theory Perspective:

The utility (satisfaction) of avoiding a $10,000 loss may exceed the disutility of paying $400, even though E[Cost] is higher. Many people prefer the certainty of paying $400 over the 3% chance of losing $10,000.

Expected value is a starting point for decision analysis, but real decisions often incorporate risk tolerance and personal values.

Question: Most lotteries have very low odds of winning but huge prizes. Why do people still buy lottery tickets if the expected value is so negative?

Answer: This is a fascinating behavioral economics question! People don't always make decisions based on expected value:

Psychological Factors:

  • Prospect Theory: People overweight small probabilities and underweight large ones
  • Utility of Large Wins: The utility of $1 million isn't proportional to the utility of $1
  • Dream Factor: The entertainment value of imagining winning

Behavioral Economics:

People often focus on the possibility of winning rather than the probability. The excitement and hope of winning can provide utility that exceeds the cost of the ticket.

Additionally, for some people, the cost of a ticket is so small that the negative expected value is acceptable for the chance of a life-changing prize.