Solved Exercises on Volumes by Cylindrical Shells

Master volumes by cylindrical shells: rotation around axes, shell dimensions, and comprehensive solutions through these 5 detailed exercises.

Solution: Exercises 1 to 3
1 Volume by Shell Method
Exercise 1
Find the volume of the solid generated by revolving the region bounded by y = x², y = 0, x = 0, and x = 2 about the y-axis.
Definition:

Shell method: V = 2π∫[a,b] x·f(x) dx where x is the radius and f(x) is the height of the shell

Shell method procedure:
  1. Sketch the region and axis of rotation
  2. Identify the radius (distance from axis to shell) and height (function value)
  3. Set up the integral: V = 2π∫[a,b] (radius)(height) dx
  4. Evaluate the integral
Region
y = x², x ∈ [0,2]
Radius
r(x) = x
Height
h(x) = x²
Step 1: Identify the region

The region is bounded by y = x², y = 0, x = 0, and x = 2

This is the area under the curve y = x² from x = 0 to x = 2

Step 2: Determine radius and height

Rotating about the y-axis, the radius of each shell is the x-coordinate: r(x) = x

The height of each shell is the y-value of the curve: h(x) = x²

Step 3: Set up the shell integral

V = 2π∫₀² x·h(x) dx = 2π∫₀² x·x² dx = 2π∫₀² x³ dx

Step 4: Evaluate the integral

V = 2π[x⁴/4]₀² = 2π[16/4 - 0] = 2π(4) = 8π

V = 8π cubic units
Final answer:

The volume is 8π cubic units

Applied rules:

• Shell method formula: V = 2π∫[a,b] x·f(x) dx (about y-axis)

• Integration: ∫x³ dx = x⁴/4 + C

• Axis of rotation: Distance from axis determines radius

2 Shell Method with Different Axis
Exercise 2
Find the volume of the solid generated by revolving the region bounded by y = √x, y = 0, x = 1, and x = 4 about the y-axis.
Definition:

Shell method: V = 2π∫[a,b] (radius)(height) dx where radius is distance from axis to shell

Region
y = √x, x ∈ [1,4]
Radius
r(x) = x
Height
h(x) = √x
Step 1: Identify the region

The region is bounded by y = √x, y = 0, x = 1, and x = 4

Step 2: Determine radius and height

Rotating about the y-axis, the radius is the x-coordinate: r(x) = x

The height is the y-value of the curve: h(x) = √x

Step 3: Set up the shell integral

V = 2π∫₁⁴ x·h(x) dx = 2π∫₁⁴ x·√x dx = 2π∫₁⁴ x^(3/2) dx

Step 4: Evaluate the integral

V = 2π[x^(5/2)/(5/2)]₁⁴ = 2π[(2/5)x^(5/2)]₁⁴

= 2π[(2/5)·32 - (2/5)·1] = 2π[(64/5) - (2/5)] = 2π(62/5) = 124π/5

V = 124π/5 cubic units
Final answer:

The volume is 124π/5 cubic units

Applied rules:

• Shell method: V = 2π∫[a,b] x·f(x) dx

• Integration: ∫x^(3/2) dx = (2/5)x^(5/2) + C

• Power rule: ∫x^n dx = x^(n+1)/(n+1) + C

3 Shell Method with Vertical Axis
Exercise 3
Find the volume of the solid generated by revolving the region bounded by y = x² and y = 2x about the line x = 3.
Definition:

Shifted axis: When rotating about x = k, radius is distance from shell to axis: r = |x - k|

Intersection
x² = 2x → x = 0,2
Radius
r(x) = 3 - x
Height
h(x) = 2x - x²
Step 1: Find intersection points

Set x² = 2x → x² - 2x = 0 → x(x-2) = 0 → x = 0, 2

So integration limits are from 0 to 2

Step 2: Determine which function is greater

Between x = 0 and x = 2, compare 2x and x²

At x = 1: 2x = 2, x² = 1, so 2x > x²

Therefore, the height of the shell is h(x) = 2x - x²

Step 3: Determine the radius

Rotating about x = 3, the radius is the distance from x to 3

Since x ∈ [0,2] and we're rotating about x = 3, the distance is r(x) = 3 - x

Step 4: Set up the shell integral

V = 2π∫₀² r(x)·h(x) dx = 2π∫₀² (3-x)(2x-x²) dx

= 2π∫₀² (6x - 3x² - 2x² + x³) dx = 2π∫₀² (6x - 5x² + x³) dx

Step 5: Evaluate the integral

V = 2π[3x² - (5x³/3) + (x⁴/4)]₀²

= 2π[12 - 40/3 + 4] = 2π[16 - 40/3] = 2π[48/3 - 40/3] = 2π(8/3) = 16π/3

V = 16π/3 cubic units
Final answer:

The volume is 16π/3 cubic units

Applied rules:

• Shell method: V = 2π∫[a,b] r(x)·h(x) dx

• Shifted axis: r(x) = |x - k| where k is axis of rotation

• Integration: ∫x^n dx = x^(n+1)/(n+1) + C

Key Formulas and Methods for Cylindrical Shells
\(V = 2\pi \int_a^b x \cdot f(x) dx\)
Shell Method (rotation about y-axis)
Shell Method (y-axis)
\(V = 2\pi \int_a^b x \cdot f(x) dx\)
When rotating about y-axis
Shell Method (shifted axis)
\(V = 2\pi \int_a^b |x-k| \cdot h(x) dx\)
When rotating about x = k
Shell Method (x-axis)
\(V = 2\pi \int_c^d y \cdot g(y) dy\)
When rotating about x-axis
Key definitions:

Cylindrical shell: A thin, hollow cylinder formed when rotating a vertical strip about an axis

Shell radius: Distance from the axis of rotation to the representative strip

Shell height: Height of the representative strip (value of the function)

Shell thickness: Width of the representative strip (dx or dy)

Complete methodology:
  1. Sketch the region: Visualize the area to be rotated
  2. Determine axis of rotation: Identify whether rotating about x-axis, y-axis, or another line
  3. Identify representative strip: Draw a typical vertical or horizontal strip
  4. Find radius and height: Express radius and height in terms of x or y
  5. Set up the integral: V = 2π∫[a,b] (radius)(height) dx or dy
  6. Evaluate the integral: Calculate the final volume
Tip 1: Shell method is often easier than disk/washer when rotating about the y-axis.
Tip 2: For rotation about x = k, radius is |x - k|, not just x.
Tip 3: Height is always the length of the strip in the direction perpendicular to the axis of rotation.
Tip 4: Remember the 2π factor in the shell method.
Common errors: Forgetting 2π factor, incorrect radius calculation for shifted axes, wrong integration limits.
Exam preparation: Practice with shifted axes, master the difference between shell and disk methods.
Essential formulas to memorize:

• About y-axis: V = 2π∫[a,b] x·f(x) dx

• About x-axis: V = 2π∫[c,d] y·g(y) dy

• About x = k: V = 2π∫[a,b] |x-k|·h(x) dx

• About y = k: V = 2π∫[c,d] |y-k|·w(y) dy

Solution: Exercises 4 to 5
4 Shell Method about Horizontal Line
Exercise 4
Find the volume of the solid generated by revolving the region bounded by y = x², x = 0, and y = 4 about the line y = 5.
Definition:

Horizontal axis: When rotating about y = k, use horizontal strips and integrate with respect to y

Express x in terms of y
x = √y
Radius
r(y) = 5 - y
Height
h(y) = √y
Step 1: Express x in terms of y

From y = x², we get x = √y (taking positive root since x ≥ 0)

Step 2: Determine integration limits

The region extends from y = 0 to y = 4

Step 3: Determine radius and height

Rotating about y = 5, the radius is the distance from the horizontal strip at height y to the line y = 5

Since y ≤ 5 in our region, r(y) = 5 - y

The height of each shell is the x-value: h(y) = √y

Step 4: Set up the shell integral

V = 2π∫₀⁴ r(y)·h(y) dy = 2π∫₀⁴ (5-y)·√y dy

= 2π∫₀⁴ (5y^(1/2) - y^(3/2)) dy

Step 5: Evaluate the integral

V = 2π[5·(2/3)y^(3/2) - (2/5)y^(5/2)]₀⁴

= 2π[(10/3)y^(3/2) - (2/5)y^(5/2)]₀⁴

= 2π[(10/3)·8 - (2/5)·32] = 2π[80/3 - 64/5]

= 2π[400/15 - 192/15] = 2π(208/15) = 416π/15

V = 416π/15 cubic units
Final answer:

The volume is 416π/15 cubic units

Applied rules:

• Horizontal axis: V = 2π∫[c,d] r(y)·h(y) dy

• Integration: ∫y^(1/2) dy = (2/3)y^(3/2) + C

• Function inversion: Express x in terms of y for horizontal axis rotation

5 Complex Shell Problem
Exercise 5
Find the volume of the solid generated by revolving the region bounded by y = x² and y = 4x - x² about the y-axis.
Definition:

Complex region: When region is bounded by two curves, height is the difference between them

Intersection
x² = 4x - x² → x = 0,2
Radius
r(x) = x
Height
h(x) = (4x - x²) - x² = 4x - 2x²
Step 1: Find intersection points

Set x² = 4x - x² → 2x² = 4x → 2x² - 4x = 0 → 2x(x-2) = 0

So x = 0, 2

Step 2: Determine which function is greater

Between x = 0 and x = 2, compare y = x² and y = 4x - x²

At x = 1: x² = 1, 4x - x² = 3, so 4x - x² > x²

Therefore, the upper curve is y = 4x - x² and lower is y = x²

Step 3: Calculate the height of shells

The height of each shell is the difference between the upper and lower curves

h(x) = (4x - x²) - x² = 4x - 2x²

Step 4: Determine the radius

Rotating about the y-axis, the radius is the x-coordinate: r(x) = x

Step 5: Set up and evaluate the integral

V = 2π∫₀² r(x)·h(x) dx = 2π∫₀² x(4x - 2x²) dx

= 2π∫₀² (4x² - 2x³) dx

= 2π[4x³/3 - 2x⁴/4]₀² = 2π[4x³/3 - x⁴/2]₀²

= 2π[32/3 - 16/2] = 2π[32/3 - 8] = 2π[32/3 - 24/3] = 2π(8/3) = 16π/3

V = 16π/3 cubic units
Final answer:

The volume is 16π/3 cubic units

Applied rules:

• Shell method: V = 2π∫[a,b] r(x)·h(x) dx

• Region between curves: h(x) = upper curve - lower curve

• Integration: ∫x^n dx = x^(n+1)/(n+1) + C

Comprehensive Summary: Cylindrical Shells
\(V = 2\pi \int_a^b x \cdot f(x) dx\)
Fundamental Shell Method
Key definitions:

Cylindrical shell: A thin, hollow cylinder created by rotating a narrow vertical or horizontal strip about an axis

Shell radius: The distance from the axis of rotation to the center of the representative strip

Shell height: The length of the representative strip in the direction perpendicular to the axis of rotation

Shell thickness: The width of the representative strip (dx or dy)

Shell volume: Approximately 2π(radius)(height)(thickness) = 2π·r·h·dx or dy

Complete methodology:
  1. Visualize the problem: Sketch the region and axis of rotation
  2. Determine the approach: Decide whether to use vertical or horizontal strips
  3. Draw a representative strip: Show a typical strip parallel to the axis of rotation
  4. Find radius and height: Express both in terms of the integration variable
  5. Set up integral: V = 2π∫[a,b] (radius)(height) dx or dy
  6. Evaluate integral: Compute the definite integral
Tip 1: Shell method is preferred when rotating about the y-axis and the function is easier to integrate in the x-direction.
Tip 2: For rotation about x = k, radius is |x - k|; for rotation about y = k, radius is |y - k|.
Tip 3: When the region is between two curves, height = upper curve - lower curve.
Tip 4: Don't forget the 2π factor in the shell method formula.
Tip 5: The shell method is often easier than the washer method when dealing with rotation about vertical lines.
Common errors: Forgetting 2π factor, incorrect radius for shifted axes, wrong height calculation, using wrong integration variable.
Exam preparation: Practice problems with shifted axes, master when to use shell vs disk/washer methods, work with regions between curves.
Essential formulas to know by heart:

• About y-axis: V = 2π∫[a,b] x·f(x) dx

• About x-axis: V = 2π∫[c,d] y·g(y) dy

• About x = k: V = 2π∫[a,b] |x-k|·h(x) dx

• About y = k: V = 2π∫[c,d] |y-k|·w(y) dy

• Between curves: h(x) = upper curve - lower curve

• Integration: ∫x^n dx = x^(n+1)/(n+1) + C

Visual Analysis: Shell Dimensions
Exercise 6: Comparison of Shell Parameters
Compare shell parameters for different rotation scenarios:
Case 1: y = x² rotated about y-axis (radius = x, height = x²)
Case 2: y = √x rotated about y-axis (radius = x, height = √x)
Case 3: Region between y = x and y = x² rotated about y-axis (radius = x, height = x - x²)

Analysis: The chart compares how shell dimensions change across different scenarios.

  • Case 1: Shell volume contribution = 2π·x·x² = 2πx³
  • Case 2: Shell volume contribution = 2π·x·√x = 2πx^(3/2)
  • Case 3: Shell volume contribution = 2π·x·(x - x²) = 2π(x² - x³)

Questions & Answers

Question: When should I use the shell method versus the disk/washer method?

Answer: The choice depends on the geometry of the problem:

  • Use shell method: When rotating about an axis that is parallel to the direction of the representative strip
  • Use disk/washer method: When rotating about an axis that is perpendicular to the direction of the representative strip

Practical guidelines:

  • Rotation about y-axis with function y = f(x): shell method is usually easier
  • Rotation about x-axis with function y = f(x): disk/washer method is usually easier
  • When the inverse function is difficult to find, shell method may be preferable

Example: For y = x² rotated about y-axis, shell method (2π∫x·x² dx) is easier than trying to use disks.

Question: How do I handle rotations about lines other than the coordinate axes, like x = 2 or y = -1?

Answer: When rotating about shifted axes, calculate the radius as the distance from the representative strip to the axis of rotation:

  • For rotation about vertical line x = k: radius = |x - k|
  • For rotation about horizontal line y = k: radius = |y - k|

Example: For rotation about x = 3, if x is to the left of the axis (x < 3), radius = 3 - x; if x is to the right (x > 3), radius = x - 3.

Always consider the geometric relationship between the representative strip and the axis of rotation to determine the correct distance formula.

Question: When the region is between two curves, how do I determine the height of the shell?

Answer: The height of the shell is the difference between the two function values:

  • If rotating about a vertical axis (like y-axis), height = top curve - bottom curve
  • If rotating about a horizontal axis (like x-axis), height = right curve - left curve

Example: For the region between y = x² and y = 2x rotated about y-axis, at position x, the height is h(x) = 2x - x².

Always subtract the smaller value from the larger value to ensure a positive height.

Determine which function is greater by comparing values at a test point within the region.

Question: How can I verify if I've set up the correct radius for the shell method?

Answer: Use these verification methods for your shell radius:

  • Distance check: Calculate the actual distance from sample points to the axis of rotation
  • Visualization: Sketch a representative strip and measure its distance to the axis
  • Test values: Plug in specific x or y values to verify the radius formula
  • Physical sense: Radius should always be positive and increase/decrease logically

Example: For rotation about x = 3, at x = 1: radius = |1 - 3| = 2; at x = 4: radius = |4 - 3| = 1. This makes sense as x = 1 is farther from x = 3 than x = 4.

Always ensure that the radius represents the actual geometric distance from the representative strip to the axis of rotation.

Question: Why is there a 2π factor in the shell method but not in the disk method?

Answer: The 2π factor comes from the circumference of the cylindrical shell:

  1. Shell method: Each strip forms a cylindrical shell with circumference 2πr, where r is the radius
  2. Volume of shell: Circumference × height × thickness = 2πr × h × dx
  3. Integration: Summing all shells gives V = ∫2πrh dx

In contrast, the disk method uses the area of circular disks (πr²), which doesn't have the 2π factor.

The 2π represents the fact that we're creating full circular shells by rotating the strips completely around the axis.

Don't forget this factor - it's essential for correct volume calculations using the shell method!