Solved Exercises on Derivatives in Polar Coordinates

Master derivatives in polar coordinates: conversion formulas, tangent lines, and comprehensive solutions through these 5 detailed exercises.

Solution: Exercises 1 to 3
1 Finding dy/dx for Basic Polar
Exercise 1
Find dy/dx for the polar curve r = 3cos(θ). Then find the slope at θ = π/4.
Definition:

Derivative in polar coordinates: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

Derivative method:
  1. Find dr/dθ by differentiating r with respect to θ
  2. Calculate x = r cos(θ) and y = r sin(θ)
  3. Use the parametric derivative formula: dy/dx = (dy/dθ)/(dx/dθ)
  4. Substitute into the polar derivative formula
Given
r = 3cos(θ)
Derivative
dr/dθ = -3sin(θ)
Formula
dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))
Step 1: Find dr/dθ

r = 3cos(θ)

dr/dθ = d/dθ(3cos(θ)) = -3sin(θ)

Step 2: Apply the derivative formula

dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

= ((-3sin(θ))sin(θ) + (3cos(θ))cos(θ))/((-3sin(θ))cos(θ) - (3cos(θ))sin(θ))

= (-3sin²(θ) + 3cos²(θ))/(-3sin(θ)cos(θ) - 3sin(θ)cos(θ))

= (-3sin²(θ) + 3cos²(θ))/(-6sin(θ)cos(θ))

= 3(cos²(θ) - sin²(θ))/(-6sin(θ)cos(θ))

= -(cos²(θ) - sin²(θ))/(2sin(θ)cos(θ))

Step 3: Simplify using trigonometric identities

cos²(θ) - sin²(θ) = cos(2θ)

2sin(θ)cos(θ) = sin(2θ)

Therefore: dy/dx = -cos(2θ)/sin(2θ) = -cot(2θ)

Step 4: Evaluate at θ = π/4

dy/dx|_{θ=π/4} = -cot(2 · π/4) = -cot(π/2) = -0 = 0

dy/dx = -cot(2θ), dy/dx|_{θ=π/4} = 0
Final answer:

dy/dx = -cot(2θ), and at θ = π/4, dy/dx = 0

Applied rules:

• Polar derivative formula: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

• Trigonometric identities: cos²(θ) - sin²(θ) = cos(2θ), 2sin(θ)cos(θ) = sin(2θ)

• Derivative: d/dθ(cos(θ)) = -sin(θ)

2 Horizontal Tangent Points
Exercise 2
Find all points on the polar curve r = 1 + sin(θ) where the tangent line is horizontal.
Definition:

Horizontal tangent: Occurs when dy/dx = 0, which means dy/dθ = 0 and dx/dθ ≠ 0

Given
r = 1 + sin(θ)
Derivative
dr/dθ = cos(θ)
Horizontal
dy/dθ = dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ) = 0
Step 1: Find dr/dθ

r = 1 + sin(θ)

dr/dθ = d/dθ(1 + sin(θ)) = cos(θ)

Step 2: Set up the condition for horizontal tangent

Horizontal tangent occurs when dy/dθ = 0

dy/dθ = dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ)

= cos(θ)sin(θ) + (1 + sin(θ))cos(θ)

= cos(θ)sin(θ) + cos(θ) + cos(θ)sin(θ)

= 2cos(θ)sin(θ) + cos(θ)

= cos(θ)(2sin(θ) + 1)

Step 3: Solve dy/dθ = 0

cos(θ)(2sin(θ) + 1) = 0

This gives us: cos(θ) = 0 OR 2sin(θ) + 1 = 0

cos(θ) = 0: θ = π/2, 3π/2

2sin(θ) + 1 = 0: sin(θ) = -1/2, so θ = 7π/6, 11π/6

Step 4: Verify dx/dθ ≠ 0 for horizontal tangents

dx/dθ = dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ)

= cos(θ)cos(θ) - (1 + sin(θ))sin(θ)

= cos²(θ) - sin(θ) - sin²(θ)

= cos²(θ) - sin²(θ) - sin(θ)

= cos(2θ) - sin(θ)

Check: At θ = π/2: dx/dθ = cos(π) - sin(π/2) = -1 - 1 = -2 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = 3π/2: dx/dθ = cos(3π) - sin(3π/2) = -1 - (-1) = 0 (vertical tangent)

At θ = 7π/6: dx/dθ = cos(7π/3) - sin(7π/6) = cos(π/3) - (-1/2) = 1/2 + 1/2 = 1 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = 11π/6: dx/dθ = cos(11π/3) - sin(11π/6) = cos(π/3) - (-1/2) = 1/2 + 1/2 = 1 ≠ 0 ✓

Step 5: Find the corresponding r values

At θ = π/2: r = 1 + sin(π/2) = 1 + 1 = 2

At θ = 7π/6: r = 1 + sin(7π/6) = 1 + (-1/2) = 1/2

At θ = 11π/6: r = 1 + sin(11π/6) = 1 + (-1/2) = 1/2

(2, π/2), (1/2, 7π/6), (1/2, 11π/6)
Final answer:

The curve has horizontal tangents at (2, π/2), (1/2, 7π/6), and (1/2, 11π/6)

Applied rules:

• Horizontal tangent: dy/dθ = 0 and dx/dθ ≠ 0

• Vertical tangent: dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

• Trigonometric identities: cos²(θ) - sin²(θ) = cos(2θ)

3 Vertical Tangent Points
Exercise 3
Find all points on the polar curve r = 2cos(θ) where the tangent line is vertical.
Definition:

Vertical tangent: Occurs when dx/dθ = 0, which means dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

Given
r = 2cos(θ)
Derivative
dr/dθ = -2sin(θ)
Vertical
dx/dθ = dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ) = 0
Step 1: Find dr/dθ

r = 2cos(θ)

dr/dθ = d/dθ(2cos(θ)) = -2sin(θ)

Step 2: Set up the condition for vertical tangent

Vertical tangent occurs when dx/dθ = 0

dx/dθ = dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ)

= (-2sin(θ))cos(θ) - (2cos(θ))sin(θ)

= -2sin(θ)cos(θ) - 2sin(θ)cos(θ)

= -4sin(θ)cos(θ)

= -2sin(2θ)

Step 3: Solve dx/dθ = 0

-2sin(2θ) = 0

sin(2θ) = 0

2θ = 0, π, 2π, 3π, ...

θ = 0, π/2, π, 3π/2, ...

Within [0, 2π): θ = 0, π/2, π, 3π/2

Step 4: Verify dy/dθ ≠ 0 for vertical tangents

dy/dθ = dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ)

= (-2sin(θ))sin(θ) + (2cos(θ))cos(θ)

= -2sin²(θ) + 2cos²(θ)

= 2(cos²(θ) - sin²(θ)) = 2cos(2θ)

Check: At θ = 0: dy/dθ = 2cos(0) = 2 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = π/2: dy/dθ = 2cos(π) = -2 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = π: dy/dθ = 2cos(2π) = 2 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = 3π/2: dy/dθ = 2cos(3π) = -2 ≠ 0 ✓

Step 5: Find the corresponding r values

At θ = 0: r = 2cos(0) = 2

At θ = π/2: r = 2cos(π/2) = 0

At θ = π: r = 2cos(π) = -2

At θ = 3π/2: r = 2cos(3π/2) = 0

Step 6: Interpret the results

Points with r = 0 are at the origin and don't have a well-defined tangent direction

So vertical tangents occur at (2, 0) and (-2, π)

These represent the same point in Cartesian coordinates

(2, 0) and (-2, π) (same point)
Final answer:

The curve has vertical tangents at (2, 0) and (-2, π), which represent the same point

Applied rules:

• Vertical tangent: dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

• Double angle identity: sin(2θ) = 2sin(θ)cos(θ)

• Trigonometric identity: cos²(θ) - sin²(θ) = cos(2θ)

Key Formulas and Methods for Polar Derivatives
\( \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{dr/d\theta \sin(\theta) + r \cos(\theta)}{dr/d\theta \cos(\theta) - r \sin(\theta)} \)
Polar Derivative Formula
Polar Derivative
\( \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{dr/d\theta \sin(\theta) + r \cos(\theta)}{dr/d\theta \cos(\theta) - r \sin(\theta)} \)
For polar curve r = f(θ)
Horizontal Tangent
\( \frac{dy}{d\theta} = 0 \text{ and } \frac{dx}{d\theta} \neq 0 \)
When dy/dx = 0
Vertical Tangent
\( \frac{dx}{d\theta} = 0 \text{ and } \frac{dy}{d\theta} \neq 0 \)
When dx/dy = 0
Key definitions:

Polar derivative: The rate of change of y with respect to x for a curve given in polar coordinates

Horizontal tangent: A tangent line with slope 0, occurring when dy/dθ = 0 and dx/dθ ≠ 0

Vertical tangent: A tangent line with undefined slope, occurring when dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

Parametric interpretation: Treat θ as the parameter and use parametric derivative formulas

Cartesian conversion: x = r cos(θ), y = r sin(θ) for direct computation

Complete methodology:
  1. Identify the polar equation: r = f(θ)
  2. Find dr/dθ: Differentiate r with respect to θ
  3. Apply the derivative formula: Use the polar derivative formula
  4. For tangent lines: Set numerator to 0 for horizontal, denominator to 0 for vertical
  5. Verify conditions: Ensure the other derivative is non-zero
  6. Find coordinates: Calculate r and θ values for the tangent points
  7. Interpret results: Relate geometrically to the curve's shape
Tip 1: Remember that horizontal tangent means dy/dθ = 0, not dy/dx = 0.
Tip 2: Use trigonometric identities to simplify expressions before solving.
Tip 3: Always check that the denominator is non-zero when finding horizontal tangents.
Tip 4: Points with r = 0 may not have well-defined tangent directions.
Common errors: Forgetting the polar derivative formula, misidentifying horizontal vs vertical tangents, not checking conditions, sign errors in differentiation.
Exam preparation: Master the formula, practice with various trigonometric functions, understand geometric interpretations.
Essential formulas to memorize:

• Polar derivative: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

• Horizontal tangent: dy/dθ = 0 and dx/dθ ≠ 0

• Vertical tangent: dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

• Parametric: dy/dx = (dy/dθ)/(dx/dθ)

• Conversion: x = r cos(θ), y = r sin(θ)

Solution: Exercises 4 to 5
4 Derivative of Rose Curve
Exercise 4
Find dy/dx for the rose curve r = 3sin(2θ) and determine the slope at θ = π/6.
Definition:

Rose curve: A polar curve of the form r = a sin(nθ) or r = a cos(nθ), where n determines the number of petals

Given
r = 3sin(2θ)
Derivative
dr/dθ = 6cos(2θ)
Formula
dy/dx = (6cos(2θ)sin(θ) + 3sin(2θ)cos(θ))/(6cos(2θ)cos(θ) - 3sin(2θ)sin(θ))
Step 1: Find dr/dθ

r = 3sin(2θ)

dr/dθ = d/dθ(3sin(2θ)) = 3 · 2cos(2θ) = 6cos(2θ)

Step 2: Apply the derivative formula

dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

= (6cos(2θ)sin(θ) + 3sin(2θ)cos(θ))/(6cos(2θ)cos(θ) - 3sin(2θ)sin(θ))

Step 3: Simplify the expression

Using sin(2θ) = 2sin(θ)cos(θ):

dy/dx = (6cos(2θ)sin(θ) + 3 · 2sin(θ)cos(θ)cos(θ))/(6cos(2θ)cos(θ) - 3 · 2sin(θ)cos(θ)sin(θ))

= (6cos(2θ)sin(θ) + 6sin(θ)cos²(θ))/(6cos(2θ)cos(θ) - 6sin²(θ)cos(θ))

= 6sin(θ)[cos(2θ) + cos²(θ)]/[6cos(θ)[cos(2θ) - sin²(θ)]]

= sin(θ)[cos(2θ) + cos²(θ)]/[cos(θ)[cos(2θ) - sin²(θ)]]

Step 4: Evaluate at θ = π/6

At θ = π/6: sin(π/6) = 1/2, cos(π/6) = √3/2

cos(2π/6) = cos(π/3) = 1/2

dy/dx|_{θ=π/6} = (1/2)[1/2 + 3/4]/[(√3/2)[1/2 - 1/4]]

= (1/2)(5/4)/[(√3/2)(1/4)] = (5/8)/(√3/8) = 5/√3 = 5√3/3

dy/dx = sin(θ)[cos(2θ) + cos²(θ)]/[cos(θ)[cos(2θ) - sin²(θ)]], slope at π/6 = 5√3/3
Final answer:

dy/dx = sin(θ)[cos(2θ) + cos²(θ)]/[cos(θ)[cos(2θ) - sin²(θ)]], and at θ = π/6, dy/dx = 5√3/3

Applied rules:

• Polar derivative formula: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

• Chain rule: d/dθ[sin(2θ)] = 2cos(2θ)

• Double angle identity: sin(2θ) = 2sin(θ)cos(θ)

5 Derivative of Cardioid
Exercise 5
Find the points on the cardioid r = 2(1 + cos(θ)) where the tangent line is horizontal.
Definition:

Cardioid: A polar curve of the form r = a(1 ± cos(θ)) or r = a(1 ± sin(θ)), shaped like a heart

Given
r = 2(1 + cos(θ))
Derivative
dr/dθ = -2sin(θ)
Horizontal
dy/dθ = -2sin(θ)sin(θ) + 2(1 + cos(θ))cos(θ) = 0
Step 1: Find dr/dθ

r = 2(1 + cos(θ)) = 2 + 2cos(θ)

dr/dθ = d/dθ(2 + 2cos(θ)) = -2sin(θ)

Step 2: Set up the condition for horizontal tangent

Horizontal tangent occurs when dy/dθ = 0

dy/dθ = dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ)

= (-2sin(θ))sin(θ) + (2 + 2cos(θ))cos(θ)

= -2sin²(θ) + 2cos(θ) + 2cos²(θ)

= 2cos²(θ) - 2sin²(θ) + 2cos(θ)

= 2(cos²(θ) - sin²(θ)) + 2cos(θ)

= 2cos(2θ) + 2cos(θ)

Step 3: Solve dy/dθ = 0

2cos(2θ) + 2cos(θ) = 0

cos(2θ) + cos(θ) = 0

Using cos(2θ) = 2cos²(θ) - 1:

2cos²(θ) - 1 + cos(θ) = 0

2cos²(θ) + cos(θ) - 1 = 0

Let u = cos(θ): 2u² + u - 1 = 0

(2u - 1)(u + 1) = 0

So u = 1/2 or u = -1

Therefore: cos(θ) = 1/2 or cos(θ) = -1

θ = π/3, 5π/3, or θ = π

Step 4: Verify dx/dθ ≠ 0 for horizontal tangents

dx/dθ = dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ)

= (-2sin(θ))cos(θ) - (2 + 2cos(θ))sin(θ)

= -2sin(θ)cos(θ) - 2sin(θ) - 2sin(θ)cos(θ)

= -4sin(θ)cos(θ) - 2sin(θ)

= -2sin(θ)(2cos(θ) + 1)

At θ = π/3: dx/dθ = -2sin(π/3)(2cos(π/3) + 1) = -2(√3/2)(2(1/2) + 1) = -√3(2) = -2√3 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = 5π/3: dx/dθ = -2sin(5π/3)(2cos(5π/3) + 1) = -2(-√3/2)(2(1/2) + 1) = √3(2) = 2√3 ≠ 0 ✓

At θ = π: dx/dθ = -2sin(π)(2cos(π) + 1) = -2(0)(2(-1) + 1) = 0 (not horizontal)

Step 5: Find the corresponding r values

At θ = π/3: r = 2(1 + cos(π/3)) = 2(1 + 1/2) = 3

At θ = 5π/3: r = 2(1 + cos(5π/3)) = 2(1 + 1/2) = 3

(3, π/3) and (3, 5π/3)
Final answer:

The cardioid has horizontal tangents at (3, π/3) and (3, 5π/3)

Applied rules:

• Polar derivative formula: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

• Trigonometric identity: cos(2θ) = 2cos²(θ) - 1

• Quadratic formula: For solving 2u² + u - 1 = 0

Comprehensive Summary: Derivatives in Polar Coordinates
\( \frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{dr/d\theta \sin(\theta) + r \cos(\theta)}{dr/d\theta \cos(\theta) - r \sin(\theta)} \)
Fundamental Polar Derivative Formula
Key definitions:

Polar derivative: The slope of the tangent line to a polar curve at a given point, calculated using the parametric interpretation of polar coordinates

Horizontal tangent: A tangent line with slope 0, occurring when the numerator of dy/dx is 0 (dy/dθ = 0) and the denominator is non-zero

Vertical tangent: A tangent line with undefined slope, occurring when the denominator of dy/dx is 0 (dx/dθ = 0) and the numerator is non-zero

Parametric interpretation: Treating θ as the parameter, we have x = r cos(θ) and y = r sin(θ)

Geometric interpretation: The derivative dy/dx represents the slope of the tangent line in the Cartesian coordinate system

Complete methodology:
  1. Identify the polar equation: Express r as a function of θ
  2. Find the derivative: Calculate dr/dθ using appropriate differentiation rules
  3. Apply the formula: Use the polar derivative formula directly
  4. Simplify: Use trigonometric identities to simplify the expression
  5. For tangent lines: Set numerator to 0 for horizontal, denominator to 0 for vertical
  6. Verify conditions: Ensure the complementary condition holds (denominator ≠ 0 for horizontal, numerator ≠ 0 for vertical)
  7. Interpret geometrically: Relate the results to the curve's shape and symmetry
Tip 1: Remember that horizontal tangent means dy/dθ = 0, not dy/dx = 0.
Tip 2: Use trigonometric identities to simplify expressions before solving equations.
Tip 3: Always check that the denominator is non-zero when finding horizontal tangents.
Tip 4: Points with r = 0 may not have well-defined tangent directions.
Tip 5: For symmetric curves, use symmetry to verify your results.
Common errors: Forgetting the polar derivative formula, misidentifying horizontal vs vertical tangents, not checking conditions, sign errors in differentiation, algebraic simplification mistakes.
Exam preparation: Master the formula, practice with various trigonometric functions, understand geometric interpretations, memorize common curves and their properties.
Essential formulas to know by heart:

• Polar derivative: dy/dx = (dr/dθ sin(θ) + r cos(θ))/(dr/dθ cos(θ) - r sin(θ))

• Horizontal tangent: dy/dθ = 0 and dx/dθ ≠ 0

• Vertical tangent: dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ ≠ 0

• Parametric: dy/dx = (dy/dθ)/(dx/dθ)

• Conversion: x = r cos(θ), y = r sin(θ)

• Trigonometric: cos(2θ) = cos²(θ) - sin²(θ), sin(2θ) = 2sin(θ)cos(θ)

Visual Analysis: Polar Derivatives
Exercise 6: Derivative Comparison
Compare derivative behaviors for different polar curves:
Case 1: r = 2cos(θ) (circle)
Case 2: r = 1 + sin(θ) (cardioid)
Case 3: r = 3sin(2θ) (rose curve)
Case 4: r = 2 + cos(θ) (limacon)

Analysis: The chart shows how the derivative dy/dx varies with θ for different polar curves.

  • Circle: Periodic behavior with sharp changes
  • Cardioid: Smooth variations with extrema
  • Rose curve: Rapid oscillations due to multiple petals
  • Limacon: Moderate variations with specific patterns

Questions & Answers

Question: Why can't we just differentiate r with respect to θ to find dy/dx?

Answer: The derivative dr/dθ represents how the radial distance changes with respect to the angle, not the slope of the curve in the Cartesian plane:

  • dr/dθ: Measures rate of change of distance from origin
  • dy/dx: Measures slope of the tangent line in Cartesian coordinates
  • Connection: We need to relate both x and y to θ through x = r cos(θ) and y = r sin(θ)

Using the chain rule: dy/dx = (dy/dθ)/(dx/dθ) where:

dy/dθ = dr/dθ · sin(θ) + r · cos(θ)

dx/dθ = dr/dθ · cos(θ) - r · sin(θ)

This accounts for both the change in r and the change in angle θ.

Question: How do I determine if a point on a polar curve has a horizontal or vertical tangent?

Answer: Use the parametric interpretation of polar coordinates:

  • Horizontal tangent: dy/dθ = 0 AND dx/dθ ≠ 0
  • Vertical tangent: dx/dθ = 0 AND dy/dθ ≠ 0

For the polar curve r = f(θ):

• Horizontal: dr/dθ · sin(θ) + r · cos(θ) = 0 AND dr/dθ · cos(θ) - r · sin(θ) ≠ 0

• Vertical: dr/dθ · cos(θ) - r · sin(θ) = 0 AND dr/dθ · sin(θ) + r · cos(θ) ≠ 0

Always verify that the complementary condition holds to ensure the tangent isn't undefined or zero.

Question: What happens when both dx/dθ and dy/dθ are zero at a point?

Answer: When both dx/dθ = 0 and dy/dθ = 0, the derivative dy/dx is indeterminate (0/0 form), which means:

  • Singular point: The curve may have a cusp, corner, or other special feature
  • Indeterminate slope: The direction of the tangent line cannot be determined by this method
  • Further analysis: May require higher-order derivatives or geometric inspection

Example: For the cardioid r = 1 + cos(θ), at θ = π (where r = 0), both dx/dθ and dy/dθ are zero, corresponding to the cusp at the origin.

In such cases, you might need to use limits or examine the behavior of the curve near the point.

Question: How can I verify if my derivative calculation is correct?

Answer: Use these verification methods for polar derivative calculations:

  • Point verification: Pick specific θ values, compute r and dy/dx, then check against the graph
  • Symmetry checks: Verify that symmetric curves have corresponding symmetric derivative values
  • Special angle tests: Check values at θ = 0, π/2, π, 3π/2 where trigonometric functions are simple
  • Limit behavior: Ensure the derivative behaves appropriately near critical points

Example: For r = 2cos(θ), at θ = 0: r = 2, dy/dx = -cot(0) = undefined (vertical tangent), which matches the circle's behavior at the rightmost point.

Always verify that horizontal tangents occur where the curve appears to flatten and vertical tangents occur where the curve appears to have steep slopes.

Question: What are some common polar curves and their derivative characteristics?

Answer: Common polar curves have distinct derivative behaviors:

  1. Circles (r = a): dy/dx = -cot(θ), vertical tangents at θ = 0, π
  2. Circles (r = a cos(θ)): dy/dx = -cot(2θ), horizontal tangents at θ = π/4, 3π/4
  3. Cardioids (r = a(1 ± cos(θ))): Have both horizontal and vertical tangents, with cusps
  4. Rose curves (r = a sin(nθ)): Rapidly oscillating derivatives, n-petal symmetry
  5. Spirals (r = aθ): Derivatives that change gradually as θ increases

Understanding these patterns helps predict where horizontal and vertical tangents should occur based on the curve's geometric properties.

The number of petals in rose curves (n for odd, 2n for even) directly affects the number of horizontal and vertical tangent points.